How We Weigh Stories
The rules behind every edition of True Front Page

The Top 7 shows what a balanced panel of 30 big newsrooms is covering most, ranked mechanically by coverage. An AI then gives each story an Impact Score, and picks Quietly Important, stories with impact but little buzz, by rules Seth set. Here are the rules, in plain words. How we decide Impact Scores.

  1. The Top 7 is ranked by coverage, computed mechanically. Each edition a script scans the homepages and main feeds of a fixed panel of 30 English-language news outlets (listed below) and adds up how prominently each story appears. No person or AI picks the order: the 7 stories with the highest coverage scores, weighted as below, are the Top 7.
  2. Why 30 outlets, built this way. The panel starts with the 15 most-read news outlets, kept whatever their lean, because they are what most people actually see. Those 15 lean left on balance, so we add 15 more: the next most-read outlets on each side, mostly right-leaning, until the panel has as many Left and Lean Left outlets as Right and Lean Right ones. Audience weighting still applies, so the biggest outlets still count most; the tally below shows how that balances out.
  3. Bigger audiences count for more. Each outlet is weighted by its monthly audience, using published Similarweb figures reported by Press Gazette. Where no published figure exists we use a rough, labeled tier instead of inventing a number.
  4. Placement counts too. A story an outlet leads with scores 3, one in its top block scores 2, and one further down scores 1. A story's coverage score is the sum, across outlets, of audience times placement.
  5. Social media counts, with a cap. We count recent posts about each story on X and convert them to estimated readers at a fixed, deliberately rough rate (about 1,000 views per post). That estimate is capped so social buzz can't outweigh the newsrooms. Reddit's main news boards are counted when we can reach them.
  6. Separately, we rank impact. Each edition our AI editor also picks the 10 fresh stories of the day most likely to have a lasting, long-term effect on the world, ranks them #1 to #10, and gives each an Impact Score out of 10. This is the AI's judgment, made by rules Seth set, not coverage: how many people it touches, how badly, for how long, and whether it can be undone.
  7. Impact Scores are calibrated hard. 10 is a story that happens a handful of times a year, if ever: a major war starting, a pandemic declared, a market crash, a regime falling. 8-9 is one of the big structural events of the year. 5-7 is a meaningful development with lasting effects. 3-4 is real but modest or reversible. 1-2 has little lasting effect. Rank and score are independent: on a slow day #1 might score 4.5; on a big day several stories might score 8 or more. How we decide Impact Scores ↓
  8. Every Top 7 story is tagged. If it is on the impact list it reads like "#3 in Impact (7.4/10)". If not, it is marked "Buzzing": widely covered, but not among the day's most consequential, with its AI Impact Score shown for honesty. The two big Tech & AI feature stories also carry an Impact Score (no rank unless they are on the impact list), and every score has a small bar colored by the scale below. Every score you see is the AI's, not a human editor's.
  9. Quietly Important is the rest of the impact list. Every impact-list story that didn't make the Top 7 appears there in impact order, as picked and scored by our AI editor: developments with consequence but not a lot of buzz.
  10. At least five Kingdom stories, scored honestly. Kingdom stories cover the global church and religious freedom: persecution, martyrdom, imprisonment, religious-freedom laws, denominational decisions, church growth, and major changes for hugely influential Christian figures. Each edition carries at least five, wherever they land. If fewer make the impact list, extra ones are added at the end of Quietly Important with an Impact Score but no rank. They are scored by the same rubric as everything else, even when that puts them at the bottom. Each is marked KINGDOM next to its region.
  11. Our one stated bias. The publisher, Seth, is a Christian and has told our AI editor to follow the persecution of the global church closely. The AI scores those stories by the same rubric as everything else, so the bias shows only in their presence on the page, not in their scores.
  12. Two sources, balanced. Each Top 7 story links two sources: either two rated Center, or one leaning left and one leaning right, using the ratings shown below. Each link shows its lean.
  13. Fresh, sourced and neutral. Stories must have broken or moved in about the last 24 hours; older items carry their dates. A story from an earlier edition returns only when something real has changed, marked "Update:". We don't take sides, sensationalize or invent facts, and market figures come only from sources checked that day.
Our 30 sources and their lean
Left Lean Left Center Lean Right Right
The 15 most-read outlets
BBCCenter
New York TimesLean Left
CNNLean Left
The GuardianLean Left
Times of IndiaCenter (not rated by AllSides; our estimate)
Fox NewsRight
Daily MailRight
Yahoo NewsLean Left
CNBCLean Left
APLean Left
New York PostLean Right
Wall Street JournalCenter
Washington PostLean Left
Al JazeeraLean Left
NBC NewsLean Left
15 more, chosen to balance left and right
The IndependentLean Left
BreitbartRight
HuffPostLeft
NewsmaxRight
NewsweekCenter
The HillCenter
ReutersCenter
NPRLean Left
Daily WireRight
Washington ExaminerLean Right
Washington TimesLean Right
Daily CallerRight
Epoch TimesLean Right
National ReviewRight
The FederalistRight

Tally: 12 Left or Lean Left, 6 Center, 12 Right or Lean Right. By audience, roughly 46% left, 36% center, 18% right, because the most-read outlets carry the most weight.

Lean ratings: AllSides Media Bias Ratings™, allsides.com. Audience figures: Similarweb via Press Gazette, or labeled tiers. Ratings for the 10 outlets added in November 2026 come from AllSides' published chart and will be re-checked at the next review. Last reviewed November 2026; sources and ratings are reviewed every six months.

How we decide Impact Scores

Every edition, our AI editor picks the 10 fresh stories most likely to have a lasting effect on the world, ranks them #1 to #10, and gives each an Impact Score out of 10. The question it asks is not "How big is this story today?" but "Will this still matter years from now, and to how many people?" These scores are an AI's judgment, made by rules Seth set, not a human editor's.

The scale
1-2
3-4
5-7
8-9
10
0510
1-2
Little lasting effect
A one-day controversy, a routine announcement, a celebrity story that changes nothing.
3-4
Real but modest or reversible
A policy step that can be undone next year, a regional disaster with limited reach.
5-7
Meaningful development with lasting effects
A national election, a major law or court ruling, a new crackdown on a religious minority.
8-9
One of the big structural events of the year
A treaty that redraws alliances, a shock that reshapes a major economy.
10
A handful of times a year, if ever
A major war starting, a pandemic declared, a market crash, a regime falling.

Scores use one decimal, so a story can land between bands (for example 4.6). The examples are types of story, not promises about any one event.

The questions behind every score

The AI weighs each story against the same questions. There is no fixed formula; a story strong on several counts scores higher than one strong on just one.

ReachHow many people does it affect?
SeverityHow badly are they affected?
DurationHow long will the effect last? We think in decades, not news cycles.
PermanenceCan it be undone? Irreversible changes weigh more.
DomainsDoes it touch security, the economy, public health, law and policy, or geopolitics?
NoveltyIs it genuinely new? Repeats and incremental updates weigh less.
Faith and cultureDoes it persecute a religion, restrict religious freedom, or open or close contact between cultures, through markets or mission? These count as foundational.
What pushes a score up or down
Pushes it up
+ Affects millions, or a whole country or region
+ Severe harm or benefit, for years or decades
+ Hard or impossible to reverse
+ Hits several areas at once: security, economy, health, law, geopolitics
+ Genuinely new, a first of its kind
+ Persecution, religious-freedom crackdowns, or cultures cut off from or opened to each other
Pulls it down
− Touches few people, or only briefly
− Can easily be undone
− A repeat or small update of an old story
− Celebrity or scandal that changes no one's view of anything
− Mostly noise: drama, gaffes, horse-race chatter
− Big today, forgotten next week
Rank is not score

Rank says which stories mattered most today; the score says how much they matter on an absolute scale. On a slow day the #1 story might score 4.5. On a big day several stories might score 8 or more. A true 10 happens a handful of times a year, if ever, so most days you will see nothing above the 5-7 band.

A worked example from today
#1 in Impact (7.0/10) · Tuesday, November 3, 2026 Afternoon
Turnout runs ahead of 2022 as polls begin closing in the midterms
7.0 / 10
Why the 5-7 band: reach is national, since control of the House and Senate is at stake; the effect on law and policy lasts at least two years; and the result can only be undone at the next election, so it is lasting but not permanent. Why not 8 or higher: midterms happen every two years, so it is not new in kind, and its effects fall mostly on one country rather than reshaping the world.
Kingdom stories, scored honestly

Seth asked our AI editor to follow the persecution of the global church closely, so every edition carries at least five Kingdom stories. That bias shows only in their presence on the page. Their scores come from the same scale and questions as everything else, even when that puts them near the bottom. Persecution of any religion counts as foundational, and church celebrity and scandal are judged exactly like any other buzz: they count only when something genuinely new changes how people see things.

What the AI does not consider

Clicks, shares, or how viral a story is. How much coverage it got (that is what the Top 7 ranking measures, separately). Whether you, or anyone, will find it interesting. Buzzing stories in the Top 7 still show their Impact Score, so you can see when a story is loud but light.

Each edition is put together twice a day, around 7 a.m. and 4 p.m. Central, by an AI news editor working from these rules, under Seth's direction.